Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label taxes. Show all posts

Friday, September 2, 2011

How Reagan and Bush Blanced the Budget


Common Sense



Just joking, we know that Reagan and Bush did not balance the budget, unlike every president since WW II until Reagan, every other president, Democrat and Republican, reduced the deficit as a percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP).So, why did the deficit go down under Carter,explode under Reagan and Bush, fall under Clinton, and explode under George W. Bush?


The answer is simple; every time you cut taxes for someone, you increase the deficit or you increase the burden on someone else, higher taxes or cut their benefits. Working families have not got raise in salary, except for a promotion or cost of living increase since 1975. While they failed to get a real raise (keeping up with the effect of inflation on the cost of living is not a raise), they did get benefits, like grants so they could send their children to college, and a variety of services we called the safety net. So long as Reagan, and then Bush, and after that, Bush again, were cutting taxes, nobody complained, and even Alan Greenspan said that paying off the deficit might not be a good idea. So the deficit kept climbing, nobody suggested taking benefits away, the middle class did not get a raise, but women stopped staying home raising the children so family income went up, and everyone was pretty happy with the ballooning deficit. It was not a problem.


And taxes keep coming down for the super rich, cut from 70% for income over (today's) $1.2 million in the Eisenhower years, down to under 20% by Reagan, Bush, Clinton, and then Bush again. The story told by Reagan and never doubted by Bush or Clinton, was the cutting taxes on the rich created jobs, and everyone got richer.


The problem was that the Reagan economic policy was what George H. W. Bush called, "Voodoo" economics. It did not work. Wages were not going up, and during the George W. Bush years, 2001 to 2009, the stock market went from 10,000 up to 10,000. That is not a typo, it did go up from time to time and then it went down, when Bush left office, it was where it was when he came in. Unless you were a banker, almost a decade wasted. Middle class wages went down and to keep up, people had to use their homes as an ATM. While the population was growing at a rate of 1.2 million new workers a year, the workforce grew, on average, under Bush by an average of less than half the growth of the workforce.


Nothing about the Reagan and Bush years was good for the middle class and working families. Time and again Reagan and Bush cut taxes without cutting spending, each time creating more of a burden to paid off later, after the reasons for the burden, tax cuts,were forgotten. Even Clinton got into the act, protecting the IT industry that would reward him so so handsomely after he left office, in what has long been seen as message to future presidents, by cutting the capital gains tax rates, the taxes on the sales of stock options that fuels so many IT CEO incomes:


"Even more interesting results arise from comparing the effects of the Bush tax cuts with the changes for investors that President Clinton signed into law in 1997. During Clinton's two terms, the effective tax rate for the top 400 (U.S. incomes) fell from almost 30 percent to 22.2 percent. Applying the Bush tax cuts yields a rate of 17.2 percent for income taxes only. That means that Clinton gave the richest of the superrich a much bigger tax cut than Bush."
- David Cay Johnson, "Free Lunch".


Like Reagan, and like "W" Bush would do later, Clinton did not cut spending, he did not reduce benefits to the middle class, paid for by those taxes, he decided to just add to the deficit and let the debt be paid long after the reason it was incurred had been forgotten. After all, a grateful nation will not pay $50,000 a night in speaker fees after you leave office; grateful CEOs not only will, they will fly your wife around the country so she can campaign.


And then the banks made the bet that even though there were many more homes being built each month than there were qualified buyers to move into, the price of homes would never go down or even level off, so loans to people with no income and no assets would always be made good by the always rising home prices. The problem was, that was the dream, the reality is, since the first mortgage was ever made, that home prices go up sometimes, and then they go down. When they went down, all bets that lenders made that prices could not go down, were lost, and the bankers turned to people who always have bailed them out, the public.



The problem now, is that with no real raise in 40 years, no raise while the cost of health care and education climbed faster than inflation, there just enough money to bail out the banks and no more.So now there were only three things that could be done; increase taxes back to where they were when everyone was doing well, give the middle and working classes the raise they wer cheated out of, or cut the benefits working families got in lieu of raises that kept up with the increases in productivity of U.S. workers, and the long hours they put in. It is going to be a feeding frenzy for lobbyists. The deficit is going to be taken care, and the burden is going to be up one someone who does not have a lobbyist writing checks to congress. You can "man up" and pay off your (and the bank's) share of this disaster or pay just seven cents a day to get a congressional representative that works for you , not the lobbyists. Think if this way: letting the banks gamble on the housing market has added $25,000 to your share of the debt, and the recession will end up costing you another $25,000 in lost or lower future wages. Figure the two now cost you %150 a a month, and if interest rates on U.S. debt go up, it can cost more. $25 a year for publicly funded elections, or $2,000 in waste and abuse? Seven cents a day to pay for a better system that ends bribes, or $5 a day keep the system that abuses you? Which sounds better?

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Left, Right, and Wrong on Taxes

Glenn Hubbard, the dean of Columbia Business School and the co-author of “Seeds of Destruction,” was a chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers under President George W. Bush. He has written an editorial (op-ed) in the New York Times (read the article) in which he states that lower taxes on the wealthy would be good for investment, as would cutting "spending" (read: jobs) by the federal government.

Hubbard, who was adviser to George W. Bush, was also the deputy assistant Treasury secretary for Tax Policy in the Bush I administration, so he advised two of the three presidents who choose cut taxes and not to cut spending, all of which led to huge deficits (see chart below). In fact, George W. Bush started a $3 trillion war of choice in Iraq and became the first president to start a war and not raise a penny to pay for it; he put the whole thing on a Chinese credit card.

If cutting taxes and increasing spending was the key to job creation, the economy would have exploded under but George W. Bush, but it did not. When Bush came to office 2000, the stock market was 10,000 and when he left in 2008, the stock market was 10,000. If you have a 401k retirement fund, it was a wasted decade. If Hubbard's concepts made any sense at all, George W. Bush and his credit card economy would have created an explosion of jobs, at least more than the eight years that Clinton was in office had created. That didn't happen. Taking Hubbard's advice the stock market was 0 for ten years, the deficit went way up, sub-prime loans went crazy, the banks and AIG had to be bailed out, and employment went into the toilet.

Hubbard argues that more money in the hands of the few would lead to greater investment, true, but the question is where would that investment be? More money in the hands of then middle class consumers in the USA would lead them to "investment" in local businesses and services, whereas greater investment in emerging markets like China, would lead to greater competition for U.S. workers, more job loss, and a larger deficit. This country is currently not short of money for investment, in fact, we have 25% of our existing capacity sitting idle. Until much of that capacity is put back to work, that is, until our consumers have some money to spend and assurance that their jobs are not likely to be eliminated, there is no reason to imagine that investors will be rushing to invest in even more capacity in the USA, and, in fact, on 19 Nov 2010, the NY Times report that "Upscale Investors are Looking Abroad" for a better return on their money. (read full article) There is no reason to cut their taxes so they can send more money out of the country.

In this argument we have one if the architects of economic failure in every important area telling us that what he prescribed in 2000, a prescription that almost killed us, will be the best thing for us now. On the other side, we have Noble laureate in economics telling us that we need more money in the hands consumers to get out of this mess.

" those parts of the private sector not burdened by high levels of debt see little reason to increase spending. Corporations are flush with cash — but why expand when so much of the capacity they already have is sitting idle? Consumers who didn’t overborrow can get loans at low rates — but that incentive to spend is more than outweighed by worries about a weak job market. Nobody in the private sector is willing to fill the hole created by the debt overhang...The irony is that in their determination to punish the undeserving, voters are punishing themselves: by rejecting fiscal stimulus and debt relief, they’re perpetuating high unemployment. They are, in effect, cutting off their own jobs to spite their neighbors.

Noble laureate in economics Paul Krugman (read the whole article)

Who are yo going the believe, the guy that drove us into this ditch? Or the guy that warned him and us not to drive into it? The Hubbard record is marked in red on the chart below, all except the little bit next to Obama's name, a disaster Obama inherited from Bush and Hubbard.



There is one critical area that Hubbard avoids completely, the class warfare that has choked off the complaints of organized labor, and denied working families the voice in politics that their numbers deserve. While the productivity of the average worker has doubled or tripled, the share they got from the increased production in the 30 years prior to 1975, ended when campaigns become so expensive that congress had to spend 100 days a year that they used to spend on the people's business, talking to, and getting money from, lobbyists.

"During the three decades after World War II, for example, incomes in the United States rose rapidly and at about the same rate — almost 3 percent a year — for people at all income levels. America had an economically vibrant middle class. Roads and bridges were well maintained, and impressive new infrastructure was being built. People were optimistic.

"By contrast, during the last three decades the economy has grown much more slowly, and our infrastructure has fallen into grave disrepair. Most troubling, all significant income growth has been concentrated at the top of the scale. The share of total income going to the top 1 percent of earners, which stood at 8.9 percent in 1976, rose to 23.5 percent by 2007, but during the same period, the average inflation-adjusted hourly wage declined by more than 7 percent.

"Yet many economists are reluctant to confront rising income inequality directly, saying that whether this trend is good or bad requires a value judgment that is best left to philosophers. But that disclaimer rings hollow. Economics, after all, was founded by moral philosophers, and links between the disciplines remain strong. So economists are well positioned to address this question."

-- Robert H. Frank "Income Inequality: Too Big to Ignore"